Since August 2014, criminal liability has been applied to legal entities in our country, as defined in the Comprehensive Organic Criminal Code (COIP). We start from this milestone, almost a decade of case law development in which the implications of attributing criminal liability to legal entities have been outlined in a range of judgments that are not very numerous, but diverse, that the courts have issued, several of which have incorporated in-depth analyses of legal and doctrinal aspects and comparative jurisprudential sources, since the criminal liability of legal persons in other countries has a longer history than in the national legal system.
Models of criminal liability for legal entities
In Europe, certain continental countries and Great Britain, as well as the United States, adopted the well-known “vicarious” or “transfer” model of legal entity liability. Specifically, Spain, with the enactment of Organic Law 5/2010 of June 22, 2010, established that legal entities shall be criminally liable for crimes committed in their name or on their behalf, and for their benefit, by their legal representatives and de facto or de jure administrators. Under these circumstances, the RPPJ will be applicable to crimes committed in the exercise of social activities and on behalf of and for the benefit of the same, by those who, being subject to the authority of natural persons, have been able to carry out the acts due to a lack of or improper control of their employees, applicable to each case.
The penalties applicable under Spanish law, depending on the seriousness of the conduct by action or omission, are as follows: Fine by installments or proportional; Dissolution of the legal entity with loss of capacity to act in legal transactions; Suspension of activities for a period of up to five years; Closure of premises and establishments for a period of up to five years; Prohibition on carrying out activities in the course of which a crime has been committed, facilitated, or concealed; Disqualification from obtaining public subsidies and aid and from contracting with the central or local government; Judicial intervention to safeguard workers’ rights.
Several Spanish jurists consider the “vicarious” or “indirect” liability model to be a model that is not particularly complex in theoretical terms, as it attributes criminal liability to legal persons upon verification that a crime has been committed by a member of the company or organization for its benefit or on its behalf. In other words, criminal liability is automatically transferred from the individual to the legal entity, without the need to determine the guilt or conduct attributable to the legal entity. The crime committed by one of the organization’s managers or representatives is attributed to the legal entity without any other circumstances, if it has been committed in the course of the company’s business or for its benefit.
Several Spanish jurists consider the “vicarious model” or “indirect” liability model to be a model that is not particularly complex in theoretical terms, as it attributes criminal liability to legal persons upon verification that a crime has been committed by a member of the company or organization for its benefit or on its behalf. In other words, criminal liability is automatically transferred from the individual to the legal entity, without the need to determine the guilt or conduct attributable to the legal entity. The crime committed by one of the organization’s executives or representatives is attributed to the legal entity without any other circumstances, if it was committed in the course of the company’s business or for its benefit. The guilt of the natural person is what makes the legal entity guilty.
This vicarious model presented considerable weaknesses when it came to defining the criminal liability of legal entities, since the courts considered that “guilt existed” on the part of the company even though the criminal conduct of the active member of the organization had little or no relation to the company’s activity and, on the other hand, the active subject who carried out the conduct did so without observing the applicable prevention rules or policies developed by the company as preventive mechanisms.
From the latter, certain corrective criteria have emerged that allow for a better assessment of the efforts made by the company to prevent criminal conduct committed by its members, which has created the possibility that, through compliance programs, sufficient evidence can be obtained of the appropriate behavior of senior management in the thorough supervision and due care in the prevention of criminal conduct. However, this does not prevent a member of the company from committing a crime even in the course of their duties.
As a result of this need to defend the company, we can talk about an evolution of the vicarious model, based on the existence of a compliance plan that allows for the demonstration of the adoption of risk management measures and procedures that are specific to the company and that respond to an organizational design that complies with the law. Separating the company from unlawful conduct in the context of the member acting within the scope of their powers or functions and at least partially for the benefit of the company, and ensuring that the conduct and intention of the active member of the organization are transferred to the company insofar as this conduct is contrary to its internal policies and regulations, such as its Code of Ethics and applicable internal regulations determined in its compliance program.
The most common crimes for which a legal entity is held liable are: fraud, fraudulent insolvency or bankruptcy, crimes of damage, crimes against intellectual and industrial property, crimes against competition and the market, crimes affecting workers’ rights, nature, and the environment, land use planning, certificate forgery, bribery, influence peddling, etc.
There is the landmark case known as State v. Christy Pontiac-GMC, in which it was held that (…) “if the company is to be criminally liable, then it is clear that the crime cannot be a personal aberration of an employee acting on his own; the criminal activity must, in some way, reflect company policy, such that it is fair to say that the activity in question was the activity of the company.” 1
In this evolutionary line, the first possibility arises to mitigate the actions and intentions of the member and the company, which generate certain exceptions in the application of vicarious liability. This led to the courts recognizing as a defense argument the fact that “when there is a clear and significant disconnect between the company’s mens rea and that of the business agent.”
On the other hand, US prosecutors recognized in the application of their policies and guidelines that compliance plans constitute “proof of due diligence,” which generated a new trend that admits that the company’s liability is independent of the vicarious model or transfer of guilt.
Compliance Plans and Criminal Risk Management
A more current model is that which deals with criminal risk management, understood as a set of techniques or procedures associated with corporate management with a certain degree of complexity and risk levels. From a criminal law perspective, this is known as “technical rules” and the relationship between the legal and criminal consequences attributed to compliance or non-compliance with these rules, creating a duty of care for members of the organization and responsibility for individuals.
The company assumes the duty to prevent any criminal conduct that may be committed in the course of its activities. The aim is to prevent what some authors, such as Gruner, refer to as the “defective performance” of business activities, which is related to the content and structure of a compliance program. Beyond the formal aspect, the fact that the company exhausts all its efforts to prevent illegal conduct has the consequence in the criminal sphere that the legal entity is not guilty of the conduct carried out by its members, which generates a possible exclusion of liability for its own conduct, related to the duty of care of the legal entity.
European criminal dogma advocates that it is everyone’s obligation to avoid harm to third parties, which gives rise to the duty to organize one’s behavior appropriately in order to prevent unlawful harm to others.
In specific cases, it must be proven whether the active subject, a member of the organization, acted on their own behalf or whether they had authorization from the company representative to act on behalf of the company. The court must determine whether the perpetrator acted within the scope of their established powers or not. The aim of the logic of attribution of legal responsibility in relation to the connection between the act of another and the perpetrator on whom the sanction falls is to justify that the harmful measure is attributable to the company or the natural person.
Under Spanish law, a company that has a compliance plan in place is exempt from liability as a legal entity.
In our country, Article 49 of the COIP defines the liability of legal entities, determining that crimes committed by them will be for their own benefit or that of their associates, whether by action or omission of those who exercise ownership, control, power of attorney, principals, and all those who have a direct or indirect legal relationship of administration, management, and supervision, and those who carry out orders or instructions from natural persons who are part of its structure.
In our legislation, the criminal liability of natural persons is separated and handled independently from the criminal liability of the legal entity, which applies in cases where it is impossible to identify a natural person who has committed the crime.
If the benefit obtained is for a third party unrelated to the legal entity, and the conduct is committed by a natural person, criminal liability cannot be attributed to the legal entity.
The general mitigating circumstances applicable to the criminal offenses of the COIP, established in Article 45, paragraph 7 of the aforementioned legal text, are applicable to legal entities.
a) Spontaneously reporting or confessing to the commission of the crime before the filing of charges that initiate the preliminary investigation, or during its course, provided that the legal entity was not formally aware of its initiation.
b) Cooperating with the investigation by providing new and decisive evidence and information before its initiation, during its course, or even during the trial stage.
c) Fully repairing the damage caused by the crime before the trial stage.
d) Have implemented, prior to the commission of the crime, integrity systems, standards, programs, and/or policies for compliance, prevention, management, and/or supervision, under the responsibility of an autonomous department in larger legal entities, or a responsible person in the case of small and medium-sized enterprises, whose operation is incorporated at all levels of management, administration, advisory, representative, and operational levels of the organization.
Integrity systems, standards, programs, and/or policies for compliance, prevention, management, and/or supervision must incorporate the following minimum requirements, without prejudice to the provisions of the Regulations issued for this purpose and other specific standards:
- Identification, detection, and management of activities that present risk;
- Internal controls with responsible parties for processes that represent risk;
- Continuous supervision and monitoring, both internal and independent evaluations of systems, programs, and policies, protocols, or procedures for the adoption and execution of social decisions;
- Financial management models;
- Whistleblowing channel;
- Code of Ethics;
- Staff training programs;
- Internal investigation mechanisms;
- Obligation to report possible risks or non-compliance to the compliance officer;
- Rules for disciplining violations of the system; and,
- Know Your Customer or due diligence programs.
Finally, it is worth highlighting the mitigating factor attributed to the fact that the company has technically implemented a compliance program and that it is being applied; depending on its size, under the responsibility of a person or body within the organization, as well as the importance of applying due diligence mechanisms that allow it to know its customers.

