Judicial guarantees are tools whose purpose is to protect constitutional rights, including, primarily, protective actions and precautionary measures. However, these can become a weapon when they are activated to nullify other precautionary measures and even final judgments issued in ordinary judicial proceedings.
It is essential to analyze the nature of precautionary measures within a criminal judicial process in order to understand the distortion of the aforementioned jurisdictional guarantees. Precautionary measures are an instrument of criminal procedural law that can be adopted against a defendant when there is a justified presumption of possible concealment of personal or financial assets. The main purpose of precautionary measures, whether personal or real, is to guarantee the full execution of the sentence that may be handed down at the end of the proceedings and to satisfy the financial responsibilities that may arise from comprehensive compensation to the victims.
Despite the legal nature of precautionary measures and the knowledge of legal professionals about them, a series of constitutional actions have recently been initiated in Ecuador against judicial orders and precautionary measures in ordinary proceedings.
These actions constitute an abuse of rights on the part of the lawyers who file the jurisdictional guarantees and a very serious offense on the part of the judges who grant them, as they act maliciously and distort constitutional actions by ruling against express provisions, specifically against Articles 27 and 42(6) of the Organic Law on Judicial Guarantees and Constitutional Control.
In this regard, these claims should be dismissed from the outset for failing to comply with the requirements of the law, since otherwise they violate rights such as legal certainty and due process for the persons who are required to set aside the contested judicial decisions.
Currently, there is a great vulnerability due to the lack of analysis in these cases, which can harm the legitimate defendant in these actions, since by not complying with the order, they face enforcement or an action for non-compliance also contemplated in the Organic Law on Jurisdictional Guarantees and Constitutional Control.
This alarming situation has been addressed by the Constitutional Court in ruling 12-23-JC/24, which analyzed cases in which precautionary measures were granted against the enforcement of court orders. The Court concluded that there is a weakening of the constitutional justice system and that all those involved acted contrary to the purpose and intent for which the jurisdictional guarantees were designed, which constitutes an abuse and fraud against our Constitution by granting measures that are inadmissible because they are contrary to the legal system and exceed the limits of the guarantees themselves.

